Writing in organisations

  • Home
  • Writing Coach
  • Blog
  • Publications
  • About

How does trust ebb and flow in relationships?

15/6/2016

5 Comments

 
Trust between humans always has both history and context. Even when we first meet somebody, context plays a part. We may already have heard something about them, or we may be influenced by their status or job title – e.g. we probably respond differently to a nurse, a businessman, a teacher or a homeless person. So in my view, if we want to understand how trust works, abstract definitions have limited value. Perhaps what St Augustin said about time could also be said about trust:

“What then is time? If no one asks me, I know what it is. If I wish to explain it to him who asks, I do not know.”

If we can’t define trust satisfactorily, can we at least begin to understand how it develops between people – and between people and institutions – over time? That is what Rob Warwick and I explored recently with a group in Brighton, by using stories, group conversations and writing to stimulate thinking.

Overall, the day prompted me to reflect on how human relationships, and trust in particular, ebb and flow. If you cast your mind back to how one of your relationships has developed over time, you may recall some striking or memorable moments along the way. Perhaps something happened to unsettle or even destroy the trust between you. Maybe you managed to rebuild it. Maybe you didn’t.

Not surprisingly, I noticed just this kind of ebb and flow during the workshop. For example, I felt warmer towards people who smiled or responded constructively to something I said. In contrast, when someone spoke in a complaining tone (as if they were a consumer who had bought a faulty product), I noticed my trust in that person sag.

At the end of the day, I came away wondering again whether it isn’t a bit strange to focus solely on this “thing” called trust, when trust is only one of several aspects of human relating. What about fear, sadness, irritation, enthusiasm, love, disappointment, exclusion, rivalry or anger? Surely these all deserve our attention.

Talking of anger, I recall how an old friend once criticised me angrily at the breakfast table (there were five of us in the room at the time). His words felt pretty much out of the blue. The memory of that exchange has lingered in my mind ever since. I would still trust him in most things, but in that moment something precious was lost, and I have gone back to it in my memory many times. 

One person at the Brighton workshop wondered whether trusting someone could be understood as “anticipating that they won’t do harm to us”. I suspect we just need to feel safe enough with other people to be able to “go on together”. 

Note: The event was the AMED writers' annual workshop in Brighton on 20 May 2016: Writing, Conversation and Trust: a day of exploration by the seaside. The original research was funded by Roffey Park.

Related reading
​

​Alison Donaldson & Rob Warwick: The emergence of trusting relationships: Stories and Reflections. Val Hammond Research Paper for Roffey Park, 2016. Available free as PDF.

Alison Donaldson & Rob Warwick: Trust and the emotional bank account: using stories to prompt learning. Strategic Briefing for Croner Publications, 2016. Available free online.
5 Comments
Rob Warwick
16/6/2016 07:36:39 am

That is a great commentary on the interweaving of the day and the subject of trust. It occurs to me how difficult this ebb and flow is to write about, it needs examples to bring it to life.

Reply
Alison Donaldson link
16/6/2016 08:19:53 am

Thanks, Rob. Do you think this blog post had enough relevant examples?

Reply
Phillip Bonser link
23/6/2016 03:26:39 am

Hi Alison
Reading this I have been reflecting on a meeting I facilitated last week. Two groups need to share some work that was previously the exclusive domain of one of them. I recall at various points being aware of shifts (ebb and flow) in the trust between them. As I recall it now this awareness wasn't particularly conscious or cognitive. So what was I paying attention to, albeit peripherally? As I reflect on the flow of the day and particular moments in it I think what most caught my attention were subtle changes in tone, most notably when described how things must be, and the responses these evoked in the other group. These ranged from annoyance to disbelief. Did we put something in the "trust bank"? Perhaps a little, but not much. Everyone heard and to some degree acknowledged the role and concerns of others but on the whole there was more ebb than flow.
Thanks for writing something that has helped me reflect. I am reminded again that writing has a powerful effect.
Cheers
Phillip

Reply
Alison Donaldson link
23/6/2016 04:41:06 pm

Hi Phillip,
I was so delighted to see you had read this piece and that it had prompted you to reflect on a recent experience. So interesting that it was tone that signalled the movement in people's attitudes to one another (or, perhaps more accurately, in their response to one another's utterances and moves). Thanks to you too for sparking further thought. Alison

Reply
proofreading services scholarship link
25/8/2016 03:54:44 pm

The ebb and flow are very frequent things in relationships, so be careful with the words you say to youe nearest and dearest and not only them.

Reply



Leave a Reply.


    ​
    I am not blogging currently. But if you subscribe, then – as soon as I resume blogging – I'll send you the link in an email. You can unsubscribe easily at any time.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Bureaucracy
    Complexity & Emergence
    Conversation
    Literature
    Narrative In Organisational Life
    Structure & Rhetoric
    Technology & Internet
    Time & Space For Writing
    Using Writing Intelligently
    Words & Language
    Writing And Reading
    Writing & Conversation

    Blogroll

    Metis Exploration by Rob Warwick

    Rob Warwick and I also blogged for a while on developing trusting relationships.

    "Informal coalitions" by Chris Rodgers

    ​Alison Donaldson is an author and writing coach, normally based in Hove, England.
Contact