Writing in organisations

  • Home
  • Writing Coach
  • Blog
  • Publications
  • About

On not being able to get a word in

16/2/2017

2 Comments

 
In recent conversations I have noticed how some people seldom if ever ask a question. Instead they launch into expounding what they think about the world or whatever interests them, without checking whether I, or others listening, seem engaged.

In the past month alone, I have experienced this at least three times and the people in question were both young and older. One of the older people was extremely well-versed in current affairs, another expressed passionate views about the state of the earth, and the younger one had strong opinions about the way society and education should be run.

All three happened to be men. I only know one or two women who monologue in this way. But not all the men that I know favour monologue over dialogue. Far from it – I have many male colleagues and friends who ask great questions and listen attentively to the answers. But still, there does seem to be a pattern. One of my friends told me that when she meets a man for the first time she applies the ‘man test’: “Did he ask any questions?” Apparently there is a word for this behaviour: 'mansplaining'!

My response to habitual ‘monologuers’ has evolved over the years. Earlier in my life I criticised it, but now I find myself trying to understand it. Could it be that these people simply weren’t brought up to be inquisitive about others? One man told me he felt intrusive asking people personal questions about their lives. Or perhaps my initial assumption – that  no questions means someone is not interested in me or my thinking – was flawed?

If (as I think) human beings co-create patterns like monologuing, we can also disrupt them – e.g. by interjecting, by bending the conversation towards a subject that matters to us at that moment, or by simply walking away.

I discussed this with a male friend recently. “Surely,” he said, “if you felt passionate about something, you would talk about it.” “Well, not necessarily,” I responded, “I tend to wait until I am invited to share my experience." I almost added: "And if I do speak, I want the other person to concentrate on what I am saying, not to look for the first opportunity to draw the conversation back to themselves or their interests.”

Strangely enough, I have also  noticed lately that it is possible to ask too many questions. Journalists and researchers (including me) are particularly prone to this bias. Occasionally I find myself at the receiving end of a succession of curious questions, and I notice that it can quickly become exhausting, trying to work out my answers. I sometimes find myself wishing the flow of questions would abate, so I could ask a question myself and shift attention onto the other person.

I wonder if  perhaps there is a range of personal tendencies or personality types  – from those who habitually talk without much prompting, to those who typically inquire first. Maybe it’s a bit like autism – we are all somewhere ‘on the spectrum’. Nevertheless, I do think ultimately that a bit more inquiry and dialogue would make the world a better place. 
2 Comments
Heinz Schmidt
3/3/2017 12:31:55 pm

Hi, Alison, wir machen dieselbe Erfahrung- Nur: Es sind aus unserem Bekanntenkreis einige - auch Frauen und besonders eine US Amerikanerin mit multikulti Hintergrund, wo wir immer davon ausgehen, dass unser "Redeanteil" auch bei der nächsten Begegnung wieder unter 10% liegt - . Deine Schlußfolgerung "better place" ist eine gute ..
Herzliche Grüße
Heinz

Reply
Alison Donaldson link
10/3/2017 12:40:18 pm

Thank you, Heinz! Great to know you recognise the experience. It is an intriguing challenge to find ways of disrupting the 90%/10% ratio. The talking stick of native Americans might not help, though it does make the problem more visible. I favour a very direct approach: drawing attention to the pattern in the moment! Takes courage but can succeed for a while... u
until the pattern reassert​s itself at the next encounter! Alison

Reply



Leave a Reply.


    ​
    I am not blogging currently. But if you subscribe, then – as soon as I resume blogging – I'll send you the link in an email. You can unsubscribe easily at any time.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Bureaucracy
    Complexity & Emergence
    Conversation
    Literature
    Narrative In Organisational Life
    Structure & Rhetoric
    Technology & Internet
    Time & Space For Writing
    Using Writing Intelligently
    Words & Language
    Writing And Reading
    Writing & Conversation

    Blogroll

    Metis Exploration by Rob Warwick

    Rob Warwick and I also blogged for a while on developing trusting relationships.

    "Informal coalitions" by Chris Rodgers

    ​Alison Donaldson is an author and writing coach, normally based in Hove, England.
Contact